So the special election for the 7th District here in Indy is heating up and the Star offers a brief q&a over a few major topics with the candidates, Republican State Rep. John Elrod and Democratic City/County Councilman Andre Carson.
What’s your position on a withdrawal timetable for Iraq?
• Democrat Andre Carson: I support a responsible redeployment plan to end the war in Iraq and bring our brave men and women home with honor. It is time for the Iraqis to take responsibility for their security, with benchmarks for Iraqi military and political success along with a responsible timeline to bring our troops home.
• Republican Jon Elrod: Like everyone in America, I want our troops home as soon as possible. I do not support an arbitrary timetable. I will listen to the generals on the ground.
Shorter Jon Elrod: “I know my district wants us out asap, but I can’t say that and get any Rrepublican votes, so I’ll pass the buck to the ‘generals on the ground’ and not really answer the question”
Carson’s answer is alright, but seems to be a bit wishy washyand lots of talk of “timelines” and “benchmarks” which have worked sooo well to this point.
What should we do about illegal immigration?
• Carson: America’s immigration system is broken and nothing has been done in Washington to fix it. In Congress, I will fight to secure our borders and make sure the laws on the books are enforced. Employers who break the law must be held accountable. I am against amnesty and believe that consideration of how undocumented immigrants can earn the opportunity to become citizens must include paying a fine, paying all back taxes, and not having an advantage over those who have entered this country legally.
• Elrod: I support enforcing the laws on the books. If the nation needs more labor, the solution is to increase quotas; not amnesty or guest worker bills.
This is the only one where Elrod’s answer is far better than Carson’s. Carson is the one who sounds like a Republican on this question. Yuck. Elrod’s is good, especially the statement that we need to increase quotas for immigration. Don’t see many GOP saying that.
What’s the best way to get the health care problem solved?
• Carson: In Congress, I will take the lead to create and invest in solutions that would make sure every American has access to affordable, quality health care. This includes ensuring that all children have health care by expanding programs like the State Children’s Health Insurance Program, passing a prescription drug plan that truly works for our seniors, and working across the aisle, and with states, to invest in pilot programs to find out what works best to lower costs and increase coverage.
• Elrod: Our third party-payer system has caused the ever-increasing health care costs. The long term solution is to create competition through health savings accounts, non-profit insurers, and public pricing.
Health Savings Accounts are a nice bandaid to help with rising costs for people who already have insurance but does nothing to help people without insurance. non-profit insurers? How will that work without massive support from teh government, and then why not just let the government handle it without the overhead of working with another group? Carson’s answer is alot better although his highlight of a state program when running for a NATIONAL office is a little.. odd. Update: I totally got SCHIP mixed up with the Indiana program called HIP. So i take back that criticism and am no longer finding it odd. Damn acronyms.
What would your economic stimulus plan look like?
• Carson: Between property taxes, gas prices and health care costs, the working families of Indianapolis are not able to keep their heads above water right now. We need to figure out ways to put cash back into the pockets of working Hoosiers. The first thing I will do is to create real tax relief for the middle class, rolling back the Bush tax breaks for the wealthiest Americans and companies that send jobs overseas, and putting these savings into tax cuts and rebates for working families. I would also like to see an increased investment in job creation for our state and nation, including a focus on the new energy economy and national security, which would bring good jobs back here to Indianapolis and create long-term stability.
• Elrod: I support a tax cut, paid for with spending cuts, that would lower the business and personal tax rates to below the average European tax rates.
Any points I may have given to Elrod for the immigration answer are taken back threefold here. I love it when Republicans say “cut taxes by cutting spending!!!” without ever saying what sort of spending they would cut so they don’t have to follow through except to dupe self-centered voters long enough to get elected **coughcough**gregballard**coughcough**. This line really takes the cake though “lower the business and personal tax rates to below the average European tax rates.” What does that even MEAN? Aren’t the tax rates of the industrialized European nations already higher than our rates here? Isn’t that one of the boogeymen that the GOP has been using forever now - the “ZOMG Europe has crazy taxes those socialists that’s what DEMONcrats want! Boogabooga!!!”
As for Carson, overall he sounds like a Moderate Democrat Talking Point Machine. The answers aren’t BAD, they just sound over-focus-grouped and bland. This is why I really wanted David Orentlicher to get the nomination instead of the Official Party Hack Approved Andre Carson. This is exactly why I got out of local politics - in the end the peopel that get slated or approved by the party are the people with the most pull among the flacks, hacks and jackasses.
To steal a line from CJ (and of course make it more vulgar, because, well, it’s me) Carson sounds like a fucking Perl script. People voting for Andre Carson thinking they are getting Julia Carson 2.0 are going to be sadly mistaken if this q&a is any indication.